Memphis Animal Shelter Statistics Examined

(Stock photo via Pexels)

For the months of January through September 2021, 112 animals died in the care of Memphis Animal Services (MAS) based upon the shelter’s own reports. Out of the 112 “Died in care” animals, 52 were kittens aged “up to 5 months”. All deaths are listed in the “In Shelter” column, none are listed in the “In Foster Care” column. As far as how Memphis Animal Services is doing this year regarding animals dying “in care”, available records indicate that a little less than half of the animals who died were kittens and a little more than half were cats, dogs, puppies and small mammals. Any claims that most of the MAS animals dying in care are kittens in foster homes are not supported by the available reports.

When reviewing the statistics for kittens during this time period at MAS, it is notable that 9 were “Returned to field”, a category normally used to report the return of feral adult cats to the community after neuter and vaccination. Since there is no such thing as a feral kitten, there is no justification for putting kittens out in the streets. This is a harmful practice both to the kittens, who should be adopted to loving homes, and the community, which should feel confident that trap-neuter-return efforts are reducing the feral cat population over time, not increasing it. No shelter should engage in this practice.

The MAS reports indicate nearly 1700 pets (mostly dogs, some cats) were transferred to other agencies (rescues) through September of this year with most going to other states. Mass transports of shelter pets are largely unregulated and tragically, pets are often shipped to states where local shelter animals are being killed.

These reports combined with the lengthy history of animal neglect and abuse at MAS, cause animal advocates to be rightfully concerned about the welfare of the pets under the shelter’s care. Compounding this concern is the shelter’s refusal to comply with the law and provide animal medical records via FOIA requests.

Even if transparency weren’t required by law, good shelters want to share their complete animal records with the public. Documenting care of shelter animals and making those records available upon request goes a long way toward building community trust. When a shelter is focused on lifesaving and consistently works to save every animal in its care, the individual animal medical records are a testament to the staff’s dedication and compassion. When the shelter actively hides these documents? Not so much.

Monthly reports:

MAS stats for January 2021 (only dogs and cats reported)

MAS stats for February 2021 (only dogs and cats reported)

MAS stats for March 2021 (only dogs and cats reported)

MAS stats for April 2021 (all animals reported)

MAS stats for May 2021 (all animals reported)

MAS stats for June 2021 (all animals reported)

MAS stats for July 2021 (all animals reported)

MAS stats for August 2021 (all animals reported)

MAS stats for September 2021 (all animals reported)

4 thoughts on “Memphis Animal Shelter Statistics Examined

  1. Aside from the decision to refuse to provide shelter veterinary records using the absurd excuse of HIPAA (which is about people only) I am surprised by these stats. I honestly though MAS was doing much better than this. The dog stats are nothing to write home about (as mom used to say) and kittens should never be returned to field. Now that MAS is part of the HASS pilot program, time will tell if that makes matters better or worse.

    Like

  2. Hi,

    I submitted a FOIA to MAS last month instead of using their trend reports. It appears that I got a bit more categorized (died at fosters, died in ACO vehicle, …) look. I received January thru a few days in September by MAS identification number. The attached link contains the most recent analysis, but at a high level here is how it flushed out:

    πŸ“ˆ 45% (53/118) of animals that died in the care of MAS this year according to FOIA records indicate they died in the ACO’s vehicles.

    πŸ“ˆ 4% (5/118) euthanized at AEC. Any stray hold violations?

    πŸ“ˆ 9% (11/118) died from failure to thrive

    πŸ“ˆ 42% (49/118) died in FOSTER CARE?

    Link:
    https://www.facebook.com/groups/1739379882976164/permalink/3011712559076217/

    Liked by 1 person

Speak!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s